Thank you for subscribing

You’ll be sent the latest news, exclusive offers and competitions to your inbox.

Australia’s Best Small Cars in 2016

silver kia cerato s premium driving on road
RACV

February 21, 2017

Australia’s best cars 2016: Best Small Car under $35,000

Winner: Kia Cerato S

There’s an air of quality and attention to detail in Mazda3, along with strong safety credentials.

The drive-away price of the Cerato S had a strong bearing on results this year. At $19,990 for either the manual or automatic, hatchback or sedan, it’s a very attractive proposition, backed by an industry-leading warranty.

Cerato efficiently tackles urban commuting but is flexible enough for longer highway journeys too. Reasonable power is available with 112kW backed up by 192Nm of torque, and for most driving situations Cerato gets around without any fuss. The Korean manufacturer has been producing its own engines and transmissions for some time now with favourable success in regards to durability and efficiency.

Cerato backed up its value numbers with consistent scoring for space, practicality, comfort and equipment. The S model lacks some interaction features such as a touch-screen control centre, which also accounts for the absence of a reversing camera. They’re in a $500 AV upgrade; it’s hard to argue why you wouldn’t at this price.

Yet one thing the S does supply which you don’t find as standard too often in this class is a front parking sensor system as well as for the rear. And it’s great to see a fully compatible and matching spare wheel in the boot.

Small Car Under $35,000
Small Car Under $35,000
Weighting
Kia Cerato S
Ford Focus Trend
Mazda3 Maxx Sport

VALUE FOR MONEY

Weighting
Kia Cerato S
Ford Focus Trend
Mazda3 Maxx Sport

Pricing

Weighting

Critical

Kia Cerato S

10

Ford Focus Trend

6

Mazda3 Maxx Sport

5

Cost of depreciation ($)

Weighting

Medium

Kia Cerato S

9

Ford Focus Trend

6

Mazda3 Maxx Sport

5

Running and repair costs

Weighting

High

Kia Cerato S

8

Ford Focus Trend

8

Mazda3 Maxx Sport

7

Fuel consumption

Weighting

Critical

Kia Cerato S

6

Ford Focus Trend

8

Mazda3 Maxx Sport

8

Warranty and dealer access

Weighting

High

Kia Cerato S

9

Ford Focus Trend

4

Mazda3 Maxx Sport

3

Insurance

Weighting

Low

Kia Cerato S

7

Ford Focus Trend

7

Mazda3 Maxx Sport

5

Standard features

Weighting

High

Kia Cerato S

4

Ford Focus Trend

6

Mazda3 Maxx Sport

6

DESIGN AND FUNCTION

Weighting
Kia Cerato S
Ford Focus Trend
Mazda3 Maxx Sport

Safety

Weighting

Critical

Kia Cerato S

7

Ford Focus Trend

7

Mazda3 Maxx Sport

8

Environment

Weighting

Critical

Kia Cerato S

5

Ford Focus Trend

7

Mazda3 Maxx Sport

7

Seating comfort

Weighting

Medium

Kia Cerato S

6

Ford Focus Trend

6

Mazda3 Maxx Sport

7

Space

Weighting

Low

Kia Cerato S

6

Ford Focus Trend

5

Mazda3 Maxx Sport

5

Practicality

Weighting

Medium

Kia Cerato S

7

Ford Focus Trend

6

Mazda3 Maxx Sport

5

Ergonomics

Weighting

High

Kia Cerato S

6

Ford Focus Trend

7

Mazda3 Maxx Sport

8

Build and finish quality

Weighting

High

Kia Cerato S

6

Ford Focus Trend

8

Mazda3 Maxx Sport

8

ON THE ROAD

Weighting
Kia Cerato S
Ford Focus Trend
Mazda3 Maxx Sport

Performance

Weighting

Medium

Kia Cerato S

6

Ford Focus Trend

8

Mazda3 Maxx Sport

7

Ride

Weighting

Medium

Kia Cerato S

6

Ford Focus Trend

7

Mazda3 Maxx Sport

7

Handling

Weighting

Medium

Kia Cerato S

6

Ford Focus Trend

7

Mazda3 Maxx Sport

8

Braking

Weighting

Medium

Kia Cerato S

5

Ford Focus Trend

7

Mazda3 Maxx Sport

6

Smoothness and quietness

Weighting

Low

Kia Cerato S

6

Ford Focus Trend

7

Mazda3 Maxx Sport

7

OVERALL AVERAGE

Weighting
Kia Cerato S

762

Ford Focus Trend

754

Mazda3 Maxx Sport

750

Australia’s best cars 2016: Best Small Car over $35,000

Winner: BMW 125i

An exquisite interior and rewarding drive overcome some shortcomings in the smallest Benz.

The evolution of the BMW 1 Series since its introduction in 2004, which has seen the model continue with its rear-wheel-drive chassis, has helped keep the German maker’s smallest model at the top of the class for driver appeal. BMW has also proven it can make cars with benchmark ergonomics, and the 125i Sport Line is no exception.

When finding the optimal driving position for your size, the 1 Series is king. Anyone can get comfortable, yet cleverly there seems to be no wasted space either.

It’s in these two areas – the seemingly telepathic handling and its brilliant ergonomics – where the 125i really puts its nose ahead of the opposition. Frankly, it really needed to in order to offset the points it gave away due to its premium price.

The 125i also has strong safety credentials, including front and rear parking sensors, a rear camera, lane departure warning and a pedestrian warning feature.

The 125i’s interior, while intimate, still conveys the message that this is a luxury car, albeit downsized into a sporty hatchback. It has everything you need and nothing you don’t. Minor controls such as heating and ventilation, audio and driving modes are clearly laid out and logical without looking like labelled kitchen containers.

Small Car Over $35,000
Small Car Over $35,000
Weighting
BMW 125i
Volvo V40 T4 Inscription
Mercedes Benz A 180

VALUE FOR MONEY

Weighting
BMW 125i
Volvo V40 T4 Inscription
Mercedes Benz A 180

Pricing

Weighting

High

BMW 125i

5

Volvo V40 T4 Inscription

6

Mercedes Benz A 180

7

Cost of depreciation ($)

Weighting

Medium

BMW 125i

5

Volvo V40 T4 Inscription

6

Mercedes Benz A 180

7

Running and repair costs

Weighting

Medium

BMW 125i

7

Volvo V40 T4 Inscription

6

Mercedes Benz A 180

5

Fuel consumption

Weighting

Critical

BMW 125i

7

Volvo V40 T4 Inscription

8

Mercedes Benz A 180

7

Warranty and dealer access

Weighting

Medium

BMW 125i

2

Volvo V40 T4 Inscription

2

Mercedes Benz A 180

2

Insurance

Weighting

Low

BMW 125i

3

Volvo V40 T4 Inscription

8

Mercedes Benz A 180

7

Standard features

Weighting

High

BMW 125i

6

Volvo V40 T4 Inscription

7

Mercedes Benz A 180

6

DESIGN AND FUNCTION

Weighting
BMW 125i
Volvo V40 T4 Inscription
Mercedes Benz A 180

Safety

Weighting

Critical

BMW 125i

9

Volvo V40 T4 Inscription

8

Mercedes Benz A 180

9

Environment

Weighting

Critical

BMW 125i

7

Volvo V40 T4 Inscription

7

Mercedes Benz A 180

7

Seating comfort

Weighting

High

BMW 125i

8

Volvo V40 T4 Inscription

7

Mercedes Benz A 180

7

Space

Weighting

Low

BMW 125i

6

Volvo V40 T4 Inscription

6

Mercedes Benz A 180

6

Practicality

Weighting

Medium

BMW 125i

6

Volvo V40 T4 Inscription

5

Mercedes Benz A 180

6

Ergonomics

Weighting

High

BMW 125i

7

Volvo V40 T4 Inscription

6

Mercedes Benz A 180

5

Build and finish quality

Weighting

Critical

BMW 125i

7

Volvo V40 T4 Inscription

7

Mercedes Benz A 180

7

ON THE ROAD

Weighting
BMW 125i
Volvo V40 T4 Inscription
Mercedes Benz A 180

Performance

Weighting

High

BMW 125i

9

Volvo V40 T4 Inscription

8

Mercedes Benz A 180

6

Ride

Weighting

High

BMW 125i

6

Volvo V40 T4 Inscription

7

Mercedes Benz A 180

6

Handling

Weighting

High

BMW 125i

9

Volvo V40 T4 Inscription

8

Mercedes Benz A 180

7

Braking

Weighting

Medium

BMW 125i

7

Volvo V40 T4 Inscription

7

Mercedes Benz A 180

7

Smoothness and quietness

Weighting

Medium

BMW 125i

7

Volvo V40 T4 Inscription

6

Mercedes Benz A 180

6

OVERALL AVERAGE

Weighting
BMW 125i

858

Volvo V40 T4 Inscription

848

Mercedes Benz A 180

810