Thank you for subscribing

You’ll be sent the latest news, exclusive offers and competitions to your inbox.

Best Family Wagon of 2016

a grey and a white kia carnival sli 2016 parked on a dirt road with trees in the background
RACV

February 21, 2017

Kia Carnival SLi is Australia's Best Family Wagon of 2016.

Winner: Kia Carnival SLi

Carnival may still look a little like a delivery van, but it is a well-presented wagon, designed specifically to carry up to eight people in relative comfort. Almost car-like driving characteristics make it easy to live with, and there is a high level of quality and refinement. Being designed and built from the ground up as a people-mover, it is well proportioned and avoids some of the compromises you get with SUV wagons.

Thanks to some important improvements in its safety credentials, Carnival has now achieved an excellent five-star ANCAP rating.

The combination of comfort and space in all three rows is extremely high. This is especially noticeable in the third row, which can seat up to three adults in relative comfort. Climbing in and out of the third row, however, is still a touch awkward. 

The SLi grade comes well dressed with leather trim, practically positioned controls and instrumentation, and a sensible range of standard features, including an excellent infotainment, navigation and connectivity package.

The diesel engine’s broad spread of strong mid-range torque, together with smooth-changing six-speed gearbox, delivers good performance for everyday driving.  

Best Family Wagon
Best Family Wagon
Weighting
Kia Carnival SLi
Honda Odyssey VTi-L
Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)
VALUE FOR MONEY
Weighting
Kia Carnival SLi
Honda Odyssey VTi-L
Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

Pricing

Weighting

High

Kia Carnival SLi

4

Honda Odyssey VTi-L

5

Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

5

Cost of depreciation ($)

Weighting

Medium

Kia Carnival SLi

4

Honda Odyssey VTi-L

6

Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

5

Running and repair costs

Weighting

High

Kia Carnival SLi

5

Honda Odyssey VTi-L

6

Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

6

Fuel consumption

Weighting

High

Kia Carnival SLi

5

Honda Odyssey VTi-L

5

Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

2

Warranty and dealer access

Weighting

High

Kia Carnival SLi

9

Honda Odyssey VTi-L

3

Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

9

Insurance

Weighting

Low

Kia Carnival SLi

5

Honda Odyssey VTi-L

5

Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

7

Standard features

Weighting

High

Kia Carnival SLi

6

Honda Odyssey VTi-L

9

Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

8

DESIGN AND FUNCTION

Weighting
Kia Carnival SLi
Honda Odyssey VTi-L
Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

Safety

Weighting

Critical

Kia Carnival SLi

7

Honda Odyssey VTi-L

7

Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

7

Environment

Weighting

Critical

Kia Carnival SLi

5

Honda Odyssey VTi-L

6

Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

5

Seating comfort - all rows

Weighting

High

Kia Carnival SLi

8

Honda Odyssey VTi-L

9

Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

7

Space
Weighting

Critical

Kia Carnival SLi

9

Honda Odyssey VTi-L

8

Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

6

Practicality

Weighting

Critical

Kia Carnival SLi

7

Honda Odyssey VTi-L

6

Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

9

Ergonomics

Weighting

High

Kia Carnival SLi

9

Honda Odyssey VTi-L

9

Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

7

Build and finish quality

Weighting

Medium

Kia Carnival SLi

8

Honda Odyssey VTi-L

9

Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

8

ON THE ROAD

Weighting
Kia Carnival SLi
Honda Odyssey VTi-L
Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

Performance

Weighting

Medium

Kia Carnival SLi

6

Honda Odyssey VTi-L

6

Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

7

Ride

Weighting

High

Kia Carnival SLi

7

Honda Odyssey VTi-L

6

Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

6

Handling

Weighting

Medium

Kia Carnival SLi

6

Honda Odyssey VTi-L

6

Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

6

Braking

Weighting

Medium

Kia Carnival SLi

6

Honda Odyssey VTi-L

6

Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

6

Smoothness and quietness

Weighting

Low

Kia Carnival SLi

8

Honda Odyssey VTi-L

6

Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

8

OVERALL AVERAGE

Weighting
Kia Carnival SLi

850

Honda Odyssey VTi-L

840

Kia Sorento SLi (4x2)

828